Employee Complained? How to Avoid a California Retaliation Claim

By Ryan Danz, Founding Attorney, Employer Guidance Group PC

Disclaimer: This article is general information about California law — not legal advice, and not a substitute for having counsel review your specific policies. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Employment law changes frequently; consult a licensed California employment attorney about your situation before acting.

Picture a Tuesday. A shift lead walks into your office and says her overtime has been short for two months. On Friday, an unrelated performance problem with the same employee lands on your desk, one you have been meaning to deal with for weeks.

What you do next decides whether you have a performance issue or a retaliation lawsuit. In California, the legal risk usually comes from how the employer reacted to the complaint, not from the complaint itself.

What counts as protected activity in California

Labor Code § 1102.5 bars retaliation against an employee who discloses information they reasonably believe shows a violation of a state or federal statute, or of a local, state, or federal rule or regulation. The disclosure counts if it goes to a government or law enforcement agency, to a person with authority over the employee, or to another employee with authority to investigate or correct the problem. That last group means an internal complaint to a supervisor or HR is covered. The statute also protects an employee who refuses to take part in illegal activity, and it applies even when reporting is part of the employee's job. Lab. Code § 1102.5

Labor Code § 98.6 separately protects employees who complain, orally or in writing, about unpaid wages, file a good-faith claim with the Labor Commissioner, or take part in a PAGA action or notice. Job applicants are covered too. Lab. Code § 98.6

The employee does not need to be right about the law. Section 1102.5 asks only whether they had reasonable cause to believe a violation occurred.

A complaint about something you already knew about is still protected. In People ex rel. Garcia-Brower v. Kolla's, Inc. (Cal. Supreme Court, No. S269456, May 22, 2023), a bartender told the owner she was owed unpaid wages and was fired. The Court held that the report was a protected disclosure even though the owner already knew of the violation. "You weren't telling me anything new" is not a defense. Kolla's opinion

Why the 90 days after a complaint are the danger zone

Since January 1, 2024, § 98.6(b)(1) has carried a rebuttable presumption. If an employer takes adverse action against an employee within 90 days of protected activity under that section, the law presumes retaliation, and the employer has to rebut it.

That presumption comes on top of the § 1102.5 burden structure. In Lawson v. PPG Architectural Finishes, Inc. (Cal. Supreme Court, No. S266001, Jan. 27, 2022), the Court held that Labor Code § 1102.6, not the familiar McDonnell Douglas pretext test, governs § 1102.5 claims. Lawson opinion

Step Who carries it Standard
Protected activity was a contributing factor in the adverse action Employee Preponderance of the evidence
Employer would have taken the same action anyway for legitimate, independent reasons Employer Clear and convincing evidence
Pretext analysis under McDonnell Douglas Not used for § 1102.5 Rejected in Lawson, including at summary judgment

The practical point is that "contributing factor" is a low bar. A legitimate reason doesn't win the case unless you can prove it with clear and convincing evidence. That evidence almost always has to be documentation created before the complaint.

What a retaliation claim can cost

Exposure Source Amount or effect
Reinstatement, lost wages and benefits § 98.6(b)(1) Make-whole relief
Civil penalty, paid to the employee § 98.6(b)(3) Up to $10,000 per employee, per violation
Civil penalty, paid to the employee § 1102.5(f) Up to $10,000 per employee, per violation
Plaintiff's attorney's fees § 1102.5(j) Recoverable by a prevailing plaintiff
Labor Commissioner complaint § 98.7(a)(1) Filed within one year of the violation (extendable for good cause)
Exhaustion before suing § 98.7(g) Not required, so the employee can go straight to court

Deadline and exhaustion rules: Lab. Code § 98.7

The pre-existing performance problem

This is the scenario from the opening, and it is the most common trap. You may have a real reason to discipline or terminate. If the problem was never written down before the complaint, though, anything you write after it will look like a cover story.

You don't have to keep a poor performer indefinitely. You do have to be able to show, with records that predate the complaint, that the decision was already on its way. If that record doesn't exist, start building it now: specific expectations, clear deadlines, and consistent treatment compared with other employees. Then let it run before you act. Escalating discipline in the weeks after a complaint is exactly the timeline § 98.6's presumption is aimed at.

The steps below are general information, not legal advice. Have counsel tailor them to your workforce and practices before you act.

What to do the day a complaint comes in

  1. Write it down. Record the date, who raised it, what they said, and who heard it. Treat oral complaints the same as written ones, because § 98.6 covers both.
  2. Investigate the substance promptly. If wages are owed, pay them with the next payroll, and check whether the same error hits other employees. Our personnel file and payroll records post covers the records requests that often follow.
  3. Thank the employee and confirm non-retaliation in writing. Keep it short and factual.
  4. Freeze adverse actions for 90 days and route any exception to counsel. That covers schedule cuts, reassignments, discipline, and termination. Get a second look before anything goes out.
  5. Separate the decision-maker. Where possible, the person the employee complained about should not decide discipline for that employee.
  6. Pull the pre-complaint file. Find what performance documentation existed before the complaint date, because that is what an employer's clear-and-convincing showing will rest on.
  7. Brief supervisors. One offhand remark about "troublemakers" can supply the contributing-factor evidence by itself.
  8. Audit your policies. Section 1102.5(a) bars rules that stop employees from reporting to agencies or to people with authority over them. Review handbook confidentiality language with that in mind.

A complaint is also often an early signal of a larger wage-and-hour issue that could turn into a PAGA notice. Our guide to avoiding PAGA penalties explains how that exposure scales. If the complaint ends in a separation anyway, final pay timing is its own trap; see how long you have to give a final paycheck.

Get a second set of eyes before you act

If an employee has raised a wage, safety, or legal concern and you are weighing discipline, talk to counsel first.

Employer Guidance Group defends California employers in wage and hour and PAGA matters and runs compliance audits that find problems before employees do. Contact us to talk through your situation.


Disclaimer

This article is general information about California law. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Employer Guidance Group PC is not your attorney unless and until you have signed a written engagement agreement with the firm.

California employment law changes constantly. The information here may be incomplete, out of date, unverified, or incorrect, and it does not account for your specific facts — and outcomes turn on facts. Do not act, or refrain from acting, on the basis of this article. Consult a licensed attorney about your own situation before making any employment decision.

This communication may constitute attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Next
Next

Headless PAGA Claims: What California Employers Should Do Now