Headless PAGA Claims: What California Employers Should Do Now

By Ryan Danz, Founding Attorney, Employer Guidance Group PC

Disclaimer: This article is general information about California law — not legal advice, and not a substitute for having counsel review your specific policies. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Employment law changes frequently; consult a licensed California employment attorney about your situation before acting.

You rolled out arbitration agreements with class waivers because someone told you they would keep a wage dispute out of court. Then a former employee files a PAGA lawsuit that leaves out any claim about his own paychecks and sues only on behalf of everyone else. Your motion to compel arbitration fails, because there is nothing individual left to send to an arbitrator.

That is a "headless" PAGA action. Whether it is allowed is now before the California Supreme Court, which heard argument on November 3, 2026. The Courts of Appeal remain split, and the latest published decision went against the employer.

What is a headless PAGA claim?

Under the Private Attorneys General Act (Lab. Code § 2698 et seq.), an "aggrieved employee" sues for civil penalties on the state's behalf. After Viking River Cruises v. Moriana (2022) and Adolph v. Uber Technologies (2023), courts split each PAGA case into two parts:

  • the individual claim, covering Labor Code violations the plaintiff personally suffered; and
  • the non-individual (representative) claim, covering violations suffered by co-workers.

An enforceable arbitration agreement can send the individual piece to arbitration. The representative piece stays in court. A headless complaint pleads only the representative piece, so there is nothing for the arbitration agreement to reach.

Can an employee bring a PAGA claim without an individual claim?

It depends on which appellate court your trial judge follows. The dispute turns largely on one word. Section 2699(a) says the action is brought "on behalf of the employee and other current or former employees."

Decision Holding on headless PAGA Status
Leeper v. Shipt, Inc. (2d Dist., Div. 1, No. B339670, filed Dec. 30, 2024) Not allowed. Read "and" to mean every PAGA action includes an individual claim, ordered that claim to arbitration, and stayed the rest Review granted, No. S289305; argued Nov. 3, 2026
Williams v. Alacrity Solutions Group, LLC (2025) Not allowed (follows Leeper) Review granted, No. S291199
CRST Expedited, Inc. v. Superior Court (2025) Allowed Review granted, No. S292005
Galarsa v. Dolgen California, LLC (2025) Consistent with allowing it Review granted, No. S293545
Castillo v. Belkorp AG (5th Dist., No. F090527, filed Oct. 23, 2026, published) Allowed under the version of PAGA that took effect July 1, 2024. Affirmed the denial of the employer's motion to compel arbitration Newest published word

The Supreme Court limited its review in Leeper to two questions. First, does every PAGA action necessarily include both individual and non-individual claims, whatever the complaint says? Second, can a plaintiff choose to bring only a non-individual action?

Why Castillo matters even with the Supreme Court about to rule

The 2024 reforms rewrote who counts as an "aggrieved employee." The plaintiff must now have personally suffered each violation alleged within the limitations period. Employers argued that this new standing rule shut the door on headless suits. The Fifth District disagreed in Castillo. It held that the definition sets who may sue, not which claims must be pleaded. It also read "and" in § 2699(a) as ambiguous and declined to follow Leeper. In Castillo's words, Viking River and Adolph "did not hold that nonindividual PAGA claims are subject to arbitration."

Two practical points come out of the opinion:

  1. The standing fight is a pleading fight. The court said a challenge to whether the plaintiff actually suffered each alleged violation belongs in a demurrer, not a motion to compel arbitration. File the wrong motion and you lose months.
  2. Candor costs nothing. The trial court faulted the employer for not disclosing that Leeper was under Supreme Court review. Any brief relying on Leeper should say so up front.

How a headless PAGA claim affects your arbitration program

If the Supreme Court... What happens to a typical SMB PAGA case
Adopts Leeper's reading The individual claim goes to arbitration under a valid agreement, and the representative claim is usually stayed meanwhile. Your arbitration program keeps real leverage
Adopts Castillo's reading Plaintiffs can plead around arbitration entirely. The whole case stays in court, and your agreement does little against PAGA

Either way, arbitration was never a complete PAGA shield. Even under Leeper, the representative claim survives in court. Exposure is driven by the violations themselves and by how quickly you fix them.

The steps below are general information, not legal advice. Have counsel tailor them to your workforce and practices before you act.

What employers should do now

  1. Pull every arbitration agreement in use, including old versions still binding former employees. Have counsel confirm each one addresses individual PAGA claims and has a severability clause that survives a waiver being struck.
  2. Do not count on arbitration to stop a PAGA case. Plan on the representative claim staying in court whatever Leeper holds.
  3. Use the cure and early evaluation tools. The 2024 reforms reward employers that fix problems early. Our guide to avoiding PAGA penalties covers the reduced-penalty caps.
  4. Audit the usual PAGA drivers first: wage statements (see our pay stub requirements post), meal and rest premiums, regular-rate overtime, and final pay.
  5. Calendar the LWDA notice response the day it arrives. The early deadlines run from that notice, not from the lawsuit.
  6. If a headless complaint lands, decide early between a demurrer on standing and a motion to compel. Castillo shows the motion to compel alone may fail.
  7. Watch for the Leeper decision. When it issues, revisit pending motions and your arbitration template the same week.

Get ahead of the ruling

Employer Guidance Group defends California employers in PAGA actions and reviews arbitration programs before they are tested. Learn more about our PAGA defense practice, schedule a compliance audit, see our wage and hour services, or contact us to talk through a PAGA notice you've received.


Disclaimer

This article is general information about California law. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Employer Guidance Group PC is not your attorney unless and until you have signed a written engagement agreement with the firm.

California employment law changes constantly. The information here may be incomplete, out of date, unverified, or incorrect, and it does not account for your specific facts — and outcomes turn on facts. Do not act, or refrain from acting, on the basis of this article. Consult a licensed attorney about your own situation before making any employment decision.

This communication may constitute attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Next
Next

Use-It-or-Lose-It Vacation in California: Caps, PTO, and Payout Rules